A cool, rocky love song, and that (second part of the) chorus is seriously catchy.
Love it.
As for the "inviting stare" (which does indeed sound a bit contradictory), just use
"The way you looked at me
A look that made me fully aware
That the things I see in you and me
...
"
and call it a day.

... and thank Ray
... by changing Okay...Okay-ay
... to Okay...Okay-Ray

(sorry, the lill' rapper in me just went a little crazy)