Originally Posted by Andrew Dee
Hi Rob!
I’ve never heard this Gershwin number, but I guess that’s understandable given the world I live in. It’s got a great feel to it. I’d be interested in hearing what attracted you to it? Is it because it had harmonica solo potential, or another reason? Good choice!
Your harmonica is as brilliant as ever, and despite you dissing your own vocal, it has qualities that really help portray the genre and set the context/scene for the song. I could imagine this in a smoke-filled club. As I have written elsewhere this week, I love hearing songs where people use their own voice - but I completely understand also why some choose to use AI or Fiverr. There’s something about having the human heart or soul on display (but your tribute to that young Fiverr man a while back was a real treat, albeit in a tragic context).
Well done - you’ve succeeded in making me want to listen to An American in Paris and Rhapsody in Blue while I do this morning’s vacuuming and mopping. Thanks for bringing this unknown (to me) song to my attention! Good job!Andrew

Hi Andrew! I did this song mainly because it was public domain. I would rather post Blue Skies, a great PD song by Berlin, but I can't seem to get a good vocal take no matter how many different approaches I try. The first two notes are an open ascending fifth and it's very tricky, at least for me. I wish someone else on the forum would sing it, then I'd be happy. Nigel would be great but he's been absent. Also, I edited out my "self-diss." Thanks for reminding me about that. If you get a chance, listen to Chet Baker's version of "But Not For Me." It's so good! Thanks also for the excellent review of my version. It's very much appreciated. Good luck as you continue your own musical journey.

Windows 11, Intel Core I5 10400, 16 gig ram, Scarlett 2i2, Sony Acid Music Studio 10, BIAB 2020 UltraPlus Pak