Hi Todd.

I think you just picked a slow day - I'd have thought you'd get a much bigger response from all the songwriters here.

I think Noel's got it about right. There's a lot of good points about the song, but always in the context of it being personal, rather than commercial. With any song like this, the delivery of the vocal performance is going to make all the difference. With so much emotion in the lyrics, it's going to have to come through in the voice to get the maximum impact. Not easy to do when you're just standing in front of a mic with headphones on!

ROG.