Moose,

"Best way" is going to be a personal decision. The BIAB for Mac route (which I opted for) will give you a program that's not quite as rich-featured, also no Real Band. Unfortunately, the cross grade pricing has traditionally been about like buying the program all over again. You can easily take projects to GarageBand or other DAW's. Probably the biggest plus - you don't have to mess with Windoze.

If you go the BIAB for Windows on a Mac route, you will have to buy Windows plus Parallels or else you'll have to do Bootcamp (still have to buy Windows). Either of these will entail partitioning your hard drive. This way you'd still have Real Band, though. BIAB for Windows always gets updated months before the Mac version does.

All in all, I think it's a compromise either way you go. You probably won't find a very big sampling who have tried it both ways (anybody?). PG Music has had a thirty day money back policy (minus shipping cost), which could let you try out the Mac version for little cost if you'd like.

Bruce


Macbook Pro 2018
2.6 GHz 6-core Intel Core i7, 16 GB RAM
OS Monterey
BIAB for Mac 2022