Quote:

First off, I will warn you that I am not going to be as gracious as Noel about someone playing armchair quarterback and taking it upon yourself to rewrite my entire song without being asked.


You are completely correct: I failed to pay attention to why you wrote the song, and provided unasked-for feedback. I apologize, and won't do it again.

Quote:

It's one thing to make a suggestion or two. You are coming off to me like one of those people who get off on critiquing other people's work just for the sake of doing it.


I understand where you're coming from. Again, I'm sorry, and I apologize. That's not the spirit in which it was offered.

Quote:

I have been writing songs a very long time.


There's no need to be defensive. Your work speaks for itself. I'm not looking for debate.

Quote:

I'll leave it with this, even if your intentions were somehow well meant, I really do not want another in-depth analysis of my work from you unless I ask for it after I hear yours.


They were well meant. I'm sorry they weren't received that way - but that's my fault, not yours.

And I assure you, you won't be asking after you hear any of my RT compositions.

Peace!

Last edited by dcuny; 11/05/10 10:37 PM.