Quote:

So this is the thread that has made it so everybody can only say great things about songs. I was wondering why most people didn't leave feedback for songs even when it was asked for.

This thread made everybody hypersenseitive and afraid to say how the really feel. It chased off most all those who were willing to help. Just look at the threads before and after this one. The ones after this are mostly (not all) puffy ego booters!

If you don't want to hear the truth abouts how others really feel about your songs, don't post them in the public square.

Saying here is my song only stroke my ego please is a bit childish and not going to happen.

I like the idea of two forums one "Showcase" no commenting allowed. One "workshop" for constructive critique.


BTW: I had some things to say about the song I really liked and some things thay may have helped, but will not post them for fear I would upset the OP.


PRearden,

To my mind, I don't think that it's possible to be more totally wrong about the purpose of the User Showcase Forum or about this thread.

I have a great deal of respect for Josie and I could not let your unjust comments pass without saying something.

Over my couple of years here, all of PG Music's forums have consisted of a very obliging and friendly community of BIAB/RB/PTP users who have given their time and expertise freely to help those struggling with absolutely any aspect of the software or music in general. Even though you haven't been around here too long, I feel certain that you've read enough of the different forums to "get" what I'm saying. Your post is different from most. When I read it, it sounded antagonistic. Maybe one day you'll need some assistance with the programs or some music and, as as result, you'll personally come to appreciate what a fine collection of knowledgeable and supportive people "live" here.

Regards,
Noel

MY SONGS...
Audiophile BIAB 2025