John,

Quote:

Well if you have a real look on a big screen TV at your vocal chords you'd get that the voice is an instrument.



Every part of the human body is an instrument. Does that make everyone on the planet musicians?

We have to draw a line somewhere. If you can't play a musical instrument, (which I know you can play several instruments), then you aren't a musician.

It's just my opinion, and we all have those.

Just because I can paint a room doesn't make me an artist. I can build a doghouse, but that doesn't make me an architect. ......

Do we want to belittle the art of of making music to anyone who can create a sound?

I'll limit the answer to my own opinion. It's a simple answer of no.

Take care and Happy New Year. I hope you have many more to come.

Bob
................................
http://soundcloud.com/bobcflatpicke/music-in-the-mountains